<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src="https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=1758373551078632&amp;ev=PageView&amp;noscript=1">

True vs. False Prophecy

The following is an excerpt from Lutheran Bible Companion, available this Fall.

The LBC, a two-volume set, covers every canonical book of the Bible, including the Apocrypha. This selection is from the “The Books of Prophets,” a section examining the Bible’s understanding of prophecy along with the classic critical views.

012112True Versus False Prophecy

How were true and false prophecy distinguished? The truth question arises almost everywhere in Scripture where the topic of prophecy appears. If we remember, however, that the Bible’s own definition of prophecy is a theological one, we will not be surprised to discover that the criterion of truth is also primarily a matter of revelation and faith.

There may have been some external touchstones. Sometimes we hear that the false prophets sought bribes (cf Mi 3:5), but there is no indication that such was a characteristic of all. Many indications, however, that the false prophets tended to prophesy what their audiences wanted to hear is probably closer to the mark. The Micaiah story (1Ki 22) is a good example, as is Jeremiah’s repeated complaint about his opposition, who proclaimed “peace, peace, when there is no peace” (6:14). Conversely, Jeremiah describes “war, famine, and pestilence” (28:8; cf 34:17) as characteristic of the tradition of true prophecy, and the scroll that Ezekiel is to eat has written on it “words of lamentation and mourning and woe” (2:10). In part such passages induced classical critics to set up preaching of judgment as a nearly infallible sign of genuine prophecy and cut out most other passages as additions from later times. That there was some truth in the observation that judgment was essential to the prophets’ message is beyond denying, but it would be lovely, indeed, if matters were that simple! The great number of judgment oracles in the preexilic prophets corresponds to the great needs of the hour.

However, in their very preaching of judgment, the preexilic prophets looked forward also to God’s coming work of redemption. And when the circumstances change after the judgment (cf Is 40–55), the prophets themselves are quick to change the dominant note of their preaching to hope and promise. The same explanation is undoubtedly to be given for the many positive and promissory oracles that are interspersed throughout the books of the preexilic prophets.

The two most important criteria for distinguishing true and false prophecy are found in two important passages in Deuteronomy. Not surprisingly, the criteria are theological. The first of these passages, Dt 13:1–5, describes what may unhesitatingly be called a doctrinal or confessional criterion. The test is in what the prophet teaches and preaches, whether or not it harmonizes with the rest of revelation. The rest of Deuteronomy, of course, is one of our major sources for spelling out the major articles of that doctrinal or confessional standard. Jeremiah’s running battles with the false prophets of his day are good collateral reading, perhaps especially ch 23.

The second passage, Dt 18:21–22, sets forth as a standard the fulfillment or nonfulfillment of prophecy. Here “prophecy” is used in a sense largely for “prediction” or “foretelling.” This passage of Deuteronomy is not alone in its stress on fulfillment of prediction as a major touchstone. The idea of predictive prophecy so suffuses biblical literature that it almost seems redundant to cite further examples. Perhaps we need note only the prominence of the apologetic argument from fulfillment of prophecy in Is 40–66, or quote the familiar refrain of Ezekiel: “When this comes . . . then they will know that a prophet has been among them” (33:33). In fact, the prophets were honored (and their writings received into the canon) after the exile—as they emphatically often  had not been before—precisely because their predictions of destruction and captivity had proved utterly true.

Very often prophecies are explicitly introduced by an “if” clause (cf Is 1:19–20). In accordance with the ancient covenant formula (cf Dt 27), whether blessing or cursing would come depended on the response (not, of course, in the sense of meriting God’s favor, but in the sense of being able to thwart it by unfaithfulness). If the people repented, God might relent and a prophecy of doom be suspended or revoked. If they rebelled, a prophecy of salvation might be set aside until God had, as it were, raised up children to Abraham from the stones (Mt 3:9). God illustrates this principle to Jeremiah through a potter’s shaping of a vessel (ch 18), and it was one of the lessons God had to teach the pouting Jonah.

Typically with long-range prediction, the entire future stands before the prophet’s eye, and the various periods or stages of fulfillment are not distinguished (cf even in the New Testament the telescoping of prophecies of the destruction of Jerusalem and of the end of the world, so that the separate events are described side by side).

In a very real sense, the problem of discerning true prophecy in Bible times must have been very similar to the one confronting believers today.

From Lutheran Bible Companion, volume 1, pages 705–7. Text © 2014 Concordia Publishing House. All rights reserved.

To order, please contact CPH at 800-325-3040 or visit www.cph.org.


Written by

Laura Lane

At CPH since 2003, Laura Lane is an editor for the professional book team. She has worked on numerous titles for the adult consumer and church professional markets, including The Lutheran Study Bible (CPH 2009) and The Apocrypha: The Lutheran Edition with Notes (CPH 2012).



Fancy Prayers and Simple Words

Bring Him your simple words and join in the lovely scripted prayers of the Church, knowing He loves our words, no matter how we offer them.


Teaching Parables: The Faithful Servant

This parable is both Law and Gospel. It’s an admonition to be ready for Jesus’ return at the end of human history, but it is also the...


What to Say to Someone Who Has Lost a Baby

October is Pregnancy and Infant Loss Awareness Month. Grieving can cause someone to hang on to every word and twist it in their mind. It...



Katie Luther & The Reformation

Katie Luther is one of the most prominent characters of the Reformation. Martin Luther's wife supported his religious and academic...


Community: Organic or Created?

Colossians is about salvation, about Jesus in all our lives, and about the connections God weaves into our lives and the community He...


Discipleship and the First Commandment

Discipleship consists of fearing, loving, and trusting the one true God above all things. To be a disciple is to have a lord, and this lord...